Lately, I haven’t been making as many pies as I once did. Probably related to two things, first, I’m certainly more health conscious than I was 20 years ago. And, lets face it, with a cup of shortening/butter/lard in one double crust pie, it doesn’t matter if the filling is all carrots, quinoa and celery, it could never be considered a health food.
However, sometimes healthy just isn’t the priority…comfy and homey is, and a pie certainly fits that criteria.
Secondly, now that I’m a little “older”, the fat and calories from a pie doesn’t fall off like it used to. Now it hangs on tightly and snuggles into my hips and thighs!
Well, this past Sunday I was thinking all comfy and homey. I had a few different varieties of apples that needed to be used, so I thought, why not. This is the result –

I had never done this before, guess I was in a bit of a rebellious mood, and in the filling I substituted brown sugar for white.
Because of the mix of apples and tart/sweetness I put in about 1/2 cup and also added nutmeg, cinnamon and some flour.
The filling was delicious!! I will never again use white sugar in an apple pie and I can’t believe I had never tried this before..
- 2 cups flour
- ¾ tsp. salt
- 1 cup shortening/ butter or lard
- (I usually use vegetable shortening or butter)
- 1 egg
- 2 Tbsp. "ice" water
- (I actually float a couple ice cubes in a little bowl of cold water and use that water in pie the crust)
- 1 Tbsp.white vinegar
- Combine flour and salt in a large bowl.
- Cut shortening/butter/lard into flour, until mixture is uniform and resembles peas in size.
- In a measuring cup or small bowl and using a fork, beat egg. Add ice water and vinegar. Beat with fork to combine.
- Pour evenly over flour mixture and stir gently with a fork until mixture is all moistened.
- Gently form mixture into a ball
- Cut ball in two equal pieces
- Form each half into a ball and gently flatten to form a disc shape.
- Using a floured rolling pin and working on a lightly floured surface, roll each disk to fit pie plate from the centre out to form a disc.
- You may need to re-position disc and add a little flour as you work.
- Roll dough onto rolling pin and transfer to pie plate
Enjoy and let me know if you have any questions.
Because I am anything but a baker, and have almost zero patience, my "no fail" pie crust uses vegetable oil. It's easy. The only stipulation is rolling the crust out between two sheets of wax paper.
I love pie! It's so easy to make and will work no matter what, how, if it works. My kind of kitchen creation.
Rosemary
I have lots of apples to use, or freeze, too. What a better way to enjoy them, but in a home made pie. I love the great photo angle, too.
I'm going to have to try this. I fail at making pie crust. My poor pie-loving husband…
I found you on the Lots of Lovin' Weekend Blog Hop! I'm your newest follower! I hope you will come check me out!! http://www.whenwereathome.blogspot.com
I love pie, but don't make it often as I use lard and it might as well be slathered on my hips!
Great post!
Hi Monica, thanks for stopping by my blog. Following you back. This pie looks delicious! I rarely make pies because of the crust… it always seems so complicated! I'm not very patient when it comes to baking or cooking. I always need instant gratification… shilling the pie may do me in! But I will give this a try. :) Thank you for sharing your recipe. Does it taste sweeter with brown sugar? I never know when brown sugar is a better substitute. I just always have both on hand in case one is needed over the other. Maybe I need to try it both ways? Have a great day,
Steph
http://www.pendantsbysteph.blogspot.com
Yum! I often substitute brown sugar for white when baking, the brown seems to give everything more depth! I love Pie!
You pie sounds like a winner. I will have to try it this weekend since I have a basket of apples waiting to be used. New follower from the sit and relax weekend hop.
Hi, coming over from FNF Blog Hop!!! I love your blog and am now following via GFC!!
Jessica Rose – Beauty and The Bookaholic
http://jessgal0430.blogspot.com
Would you believe I've never made a pie?!
Yes… it's the perfect time for apple pie. I made one the other day. :)
oh my this looks perfect! cannot wait to give it a try!
Not Your Ordinary Agent
Not Your Ordinary Recipes
Clean Gal